Skip to content

Chappaqua Poison

NY Family Court

7 chapters

All chapters tagged with NY Family Court

Act V

Chapter 25 ●

A Special Relationship

The court appoints a supervisor who promises integrity and transparency. She meets privately with Tara before the first visit, invites her to attend in violation of the court order, dismisses Steve's concerns about being poisoned, and tells him she has a special relationship with the judge. She charges $250 an hour. The judge who appointed her later says on the record that she never wanted Tara at the visits and wanted Steve to die on his own sword, so the court would know.

October–November 2018
Chapter 29 ●

The Memo

Steve files a detailed memorandum describing the ambush, the supervision manipulation, and the historical abuse inside the Walsh household. The court destabilizes. The judge recuses. The case is reassigned.

2019

Act VII

Chapter 32 ●

Five O'Clock

Aunt K undergoes surgery days before the hearing. Steve's attorneys request remote appearance at a visitation conference. At the last minute — the afternoon before — the court denies the request. Steve books the next available flight, 6:20 the next morning. When he arrives, Judge Horowitz has already entered a default — granting permanent custody and a two-year order of protection at what was scheduled as a status conference. Fourteen months later, his motion to vacate is still pending when the third judge recuses.

February 6, 2020
Chapter 33 ●

Two Defaults

Steve seeks recognition in New York of the protection he won against Tara after a San Francisco hearing. Humphrey warns Steve about nonappearance, but gives him no ruling after Tara misses two hearings. Humphrey then recuses. Aunt K investigates the court's evaluator.

2020–2021
Chapter 35 ●

Equal Threats

The case passes to a fourth judge. At a twenty-three-minute video appearance Schauer vacates the Horowitz default on consent and issues mirroring stay-away orders — one against each party — rather than address the California restraining order against Tara. The poisoner and the poisoned are treated as symmetrical threats, and neither petition is heard. Steve tells the court a permanent temporary order does not give him a chance to face his accuser. The court tells him he is muddying the record.

May 19, 2021
Chapter 37 ●

Erase, Deactivate, and Delete

Jennifer Jackman resigns as Attorney for the Child without explanation. Her replacement files a motion to suppress all blog content. A visitation conference is converted into a gag order hearing. Steve is declared in default. Judge Schauer orders the blog removed — every post, every photograph, every grandmother's letter. The words are precise. Erase. Deactivate. Delete.

November 5, 2021
Chapter 38 ●

Bora Bora

His attorney was in the courtroom. He was not. The phone rang after. The voice on the other end sounded beaten. 'Well, that didn't go well.' The orders were final.

January 5, 2022