Mom's side of the story is riddled with inaccuracies, shifty storytelling, and straight-up lies. These are their truths.

The Truth: Mom surreptitiously recorded and took photos of Dad in the privacy of his home. She then used these videos to extort him.

Mom recorded videos and took photos of Dad in the privacy of his own home and during medical examinations. Once caught she hid under the guise that she might "show him" how he was behaving. These recordings, made without consent, were illegal.

Not only were the recordings illegal in their creation, the myriad of purposes that Mom used them for were also highly illegal – she extorted him, she claimed she was going to use them to write a book, she was sanctioned for refusing to produce them, and she offered them to known con men.

Selfie of Mom & Dad – taken without Dad's knowledge.
Selfie of Mom & Dad – taken without Dad's knowledge.

Members can see the evidence for themselves:


The Lie: Mom secretly recorded Dad to "help" him and to "show" him.

Mom Testimony, California Hearing for Domestic Violence Restraining Order, 10/31/2019.
Mom Testimony, California Hearing for Domestic Violence Restraining Order, 10/31/2019.
Mom Testimony, California Hearing for Domestic Violence Restraining Order, 10/31/2019.
Mom Testimony, California Hearing for Domestic Violence Restraining Order, 10/31/2019.

The Lie: Mom never intended to release the videos.

Mom Testimony, California Hearing for Domestic Violence Restraining Order, 10/31/2019.
Mom Testimony, California Hearing for Domestic Violence Restraining Order, 10/31/2019.

The Truth: Dad did not know he was being recorded.

Mom Testimony, California Hearing for Domestic Violence Restraining Order, 10/31/2019.
Mom Testimony, California Hearing for Domestic Violence Restraining Order, 10/31/2019.

This is illegal under California Recording Law:

The Truth: Mom's recordings often occurred shortly after Dad suspected he was drugged.

DVRO Hearing San Francisco, Exhibits 24 - 31, 10/31/2019.
DVRO Hearing San Francisco, Exhibits 24 - 31, 10/31/2019.

Mom's first secret video was taken in September 2016 – the same time Dad started feeling ill, and shortly before he tested positive for Lithium.

The Truth: Mom set up hidden cameras in her New York apartment in early 2017, before Evie was even conceived

Dad's (extremely high) Lithium test results, March 2017
Dad's (extremely high) Lithium test results, March 2017

The Truth: Mom distributed the videos to friends and family, and intended to release them.

Produced in San Francisco DVRO Hearing, 10/25/2019
Produced in San Francisco DVRO Hearing, 10/25/2019
Produced in San Francisco Civil Battery Case, Russell v. Walsh, WALSH_003595-6
Produced in San Francisco Civil Battery Case, Russell v. Walsh, WALSH_003595-6

The Truth: Mom has offered the videos and other fabricated evidence to con men Nir and George – who are currently under FBI indictment.

Produced in San Francisco Civil Battery Case, Russell v. Walsh, WALSH_005693
Produced in San Francisco Civil Battery Case, Russell v. Walsh, WALSH_005693

The Truth: Mom threatened to release the videos if Dad did not drop the civil case and give her more 'child support.'

"I have a bunch of videos. I have a bunch of photos... I have stuff you haven't seen yet."
"I have a bunch of videos. I have a bunch of photos... I have stuff you haven't seen yet."

The Truth: Mom has refused court orders to produce the videos for a hearing and refused to agree that they not be released.

Mom's testimony, California Hearing for Domestic Violence Restraing Order, 10/31/2019
Mom's testimony, California Hearing for Domestic Violence Restraing Order, 10/31/2019

The Truth: At the close of these proceedings, Dad was granted a permanent restraining order against Mom in San Francisco.